we-rate-stuff.com
We Rate Stuff



Food & Drink

April 8, 2009

Papa John’s XL X-treme Cheese Pizza

More articles by Brad »
Written by: Brad
Tags: , ,
t-xl-xtreme

I’ve always thought that Papa John’s was an under-rated pizza place; their pies taste great, and they even give you peppers and some unbelievably greasy garlic sauce to wash it down. Mysteriously enough, I even know some people that don’t like it. With their new XL X-treme Cheese pizza, though, that might change. If they’re fans of cheese, at least.

Advertised as having “nearly a pound” of cheese, all natural pizza sauce, and their patented X-TRA large hand-tossed crust, this pizza delivers on all fronts, and then some. Let’s start with the size. It’s enormous. It’s apparently 33% bigger than their large pizza, so that should give you some idea as to its gargantuan proportions. It comes in “10 huge pieces”, whose hugeness I can indeed verify. The cheese is the main attraction here, though; if you don’t like a lot of cheese, absolutely do not get this pizza, because it comes loaded. Think about the layer of cheese on a normal slice of pizza, and then double it, and that’s basically this pizza. I dunno about nearly a pound of mozzarella, but it’s pretty damn satisfactory. And I like a lot of cheese. The crust is equally delicious; it’s thick and doughy and chewy, and blends great with the thick layer of cheese. The sauce, to top it all off, is tangy and fresh tasting, and has been toned down a smidge to give the cheese the spotlight.

Now, here comes the best part. I’m pleased to announce that all of this goodness is available to you for a very, very reasonable price of $12.83. THIRTEEN bucks?! You can’t even get a large pizza at Pizza Hut for that! For example, the Italian Meat Classicana pizza, a much lesser pizza, will run you a cool $15. Poor college guys, you have found your holy grail. It’ll fill you right up with 8 pieces (basically a full pizza) to spare. Capitalize on this beast while you still can; it’s entirely worth it.

7/7

About the Author

Brad
Brad Cook is the guy who wrote this, for better or worse. He co-founded We Rate Stuff, used to be in a ska band called CIO, and prefers grape jelly in his PB&Js.




 
 

 
Wendy's Signature Sides Review

Wendy’s Signature Sides

Old Wendy has been revamping her menu items and introducing entirely new ones recently, and she continues this trend with Wendy's Signature Sides - Vermont Cheddar Macaroni, a Sweet Potato with Cinnamon Butter, and Loaded Fries.
by Ben
2

 
 
Wendy's Cheesy Cheddar Burger Review

Wendy’s Cheesy Cheddar Burger

There are a lot of things you can do with a burger, but arguably one of the best is to add cheese. Not plain old American cheese, but Cheddar. Wendy's has made the attempt, but did they cheese it up right?
by Kaitis
0

 
 
Snyder's of Hanover Three Cheese Medley Sourdough Nibblers Review

Snyder’s of Hanover Three Cheese Medley Nibblers

Snyder's of Hanover claims to be America's Pretzel Bakery since 1909. I don't know about that, but they've been mine since about 2007. I tried out their new Three Cheese Medley Sourdough Nibblers.
by Brad
0

 

 
cheesypoofs

I love Cheesy Poofs, you love Cheesy Poofs…

...if we didn't love Cheesy Poofs we'd be lame. Now you get an actual chance to be lame!
by Brad
1

 
 
Colby Cheez-It review

Colby Cheez-Its

Bob Cheez-It (the CEO I just made up) and co. are basically the masters of artificial cheese flavors, and they've got another one to stick up your craw: Colby. Kaitis crawed 'em up for you and spit out these words.
by Kaitis
5

 




7 Comments


  1. >I can’t remember the last time I had a cheese pizza. $13 bucks is a good deal…33% larger than their large…Is their large 14″? So it would make it around 18 or 19″…that’s huge.


  2. >Ryan, I assume they’re claiming the area–not diameter–is 33% bigger than their large. So, if the large is 14″, that would make the XL a hair over 16″.


  3. >I haven’t been able to take a dump since I ate this pizza 12 days ago.


  4. >You might want to take some psyllium, anon.Or see a doctor. Either one.


  5. eww this pizza was so so so bad i puked after i had it


  6. Papa John's is yummy. Great prices, polite workers. Keep up the good work! One-of-a-kind pizza. 10/10



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>